Connect with us

OnlySP 50 Favorite Games

OnlySP’s Favorite Games #14—Dark Chronicle



OnlySP Favorite Games 14 - Dark Chronicle

Thanks to the staff of OnlySP, I am inviting you to come on a journey through our 50 favourite games. This week we venture once more into the nostalgic past with an absolutely top game for its time, whose sheer breadth is rarely rivalled in action-RPGs even today.

#14. Dark Chronicle, by Mitchell Akhurst

A quick way to determine if one’s favourite game will stand the test of time is whether it engenders unrealistic demands for other games. These are the unique voices, the big-budget blockbusters, the risky one-offs, or even those seven out of ten oddities that just tweak the right knobs in one’s brain. God of War. Red Dead Redemption. Deus Ex. Last week’s game, Conker’s Bad Fur Day.

Dark Chronicle, also known as Dark Cloud 2 in North America, was not the first Japanese action-RPG I played—nor the most polished or popular—but it took hold of my heart and never let go. Dark Chronicle‘s aesthetics, combat design, and sheer level of variety came at the exact right time in gaming’s history, and since its release, few adventures have been able to do everything it accomplished.

Not Your Average JRPG

As a fan of anime, you might think I’m also a fan of Japanese RPGs. Yet—though I have deeply loved a handful of JRPGs and enjoyed the soundtracks of many more—RPGs, in general, are a bad genre for me. With their sheer length, formulaic storytelling, and repetitive grinding, it takes a very special JRPG to grip me enough to see it through to the end.

Dark Chronicle was one such game. As an action-RPG with no small influence from The Legend of Zelda, the tone and aesthetics are not dissimilar to other timey-wimey anime adventures, filled with dorky heroes, sentimental music, and dramatic villains (or maybe dramatic heroes, dorky music and sentimental villains—mix and match to taste).

There is no surprise that the same team would go on to develop Dragon Quest VIII several years later. Dark Chronicle delivers the flavour of Shonen Jump and/or Saturday-morning sorts of adventures with aplomb: there are steampunky mechas, floating castles, fairy-tale forests, and an evil clown besides—all wrapped up in a time travelling narrative that, though not as intricate as Chrono Trigger, is represented mechanically through the player’s interaction with the world (more on that below).

Perhaps the least accomplished element of Dark Chronicle‘s magical world, then, was the synthetic soundtrack. Compositionally, the sounds are approximate to Zelda and Chrono Trigger in ambition, but the quality of virtual instruments was slightly out-of-date even in 2003.

Tomohito Nishiura’s music defines much of developer Level-5’s early catalogue, and he received a sort of pardon for this lo-fi music style on the Professor Layton games since they were Nintendo DS titles. For something on the PlayStation 2 however, Dark Chronicle‘s soundtrack is a little cheap compared with its contemporaries.

Action-RPG Evolution

The older PlayStation 1 and 2 style of action-RPG sees very little AAA play in the modern era. Kingdom Hearts III proved that, with the right level of marketing, these hack-and-slash, experience-driven games can still win over huge audiences, but that still requires confidence from the publisher.

Dark Chronicle had that publisher support. The first Dark Cloud was a naked attempt at producing something Sony could tout as “its Zelda game”, and it was an okay, if clunky, game in its own right that could never hold a candle to Nintendo’s output. The sequel, though, was allowed to go in a direction all its own—still maintaining the Zelda connection, but experimenting with systems that took another ten years or more to see finally trickling down into other games (mostly indie games like Stardew Valley or Recettear).

Firstly, Dark Chronicle does not even attempt to compete with the puzzle dungeons of The Legend of Zelda series, instead refining the procedural dungeons of its predecessor. This means that each of the game’s dungeon areas (following the traditional JRPG tropes of magical forests, sprawling sewers, fiery caves, and so on) has a long list of floors, each with their own list of enemies and features that are then arranged in a semi-random configuration.

These dungeons are the closest that Dark Chronicle comes to the tedium of some turn-based RPGs, given their length, but the nuts and bolts of the action combat alleviate this mostly by being rather fun. The two main playable characters, Max and Monica, lack traditional stat blocks, instead upgrading their melee and ranged weapons with experience collectables that drop from defeated enemies. Mixing melee and ranged combat against different enemies becomes essential, but those are not the only options players are given.

Max comes with his own homemade mecha, the Ridepod, which gives him a massive damage boost and has its own upgradable body parts, while Monica can transform into various monsters of the dungeon. This increases the effective party size to four, though players only control one at any time during their adventures.

Along with experience, enemies drop a variety of materials: slimes, lumber, seeds, food, metals, etc. Basically, everything modern crafting-game players will be familiar with—and these raw materials fuel the aforementioned world interaction in surprising ways.

“The Adventure With Everything”

The primary reason that Dark Chronicle set unrealistic expectations of action-RPGs for my young mind was its chief sales tactic. Ads would describe the game as “The Adventure With Everything”, touting the insane variety of activities, and they were not being especially hyperbolic about it.

As a prospective Zelda rival, there are the side-quests and fetch quests, the many NPCs to interact with and, of course, fishing. But the fishing minigame was not just for one watering hole. Any large enough pond or waterway could be fished in at will, even inside dungeon levels once the enemies had been taken care of.

Fishing pervades every mechanic in the game, the same way that weapons or magic does. Different kinds of bait and lures could be discovered all over the world, or bought in town. Once fished, players could take care of their catch in an aquarium, grow them, and sell the choicest morsels, or attempt to breed rare species.

This extreme level of detail applies to every facet of the experience—photography, upgrading the Ridepod, costumes, finding homes for NPCs, and even a version of golf called Spheda. But above all, one mode took each of these elements and tied them together. Called “Georama”, the city-building side of Dark Chronicle is by no means as deep as SimCity, but still deep enough to allow for customising your own towns all over the game world.

These towns require the raw materials collected in dungeons, allowing tangible, world-changing experiences instead of crafting recipes. Some towns need lakes, others need fireproof roofs, and you can bet that you could fish in those lakes, or go inside those houses after you found the right NPC to live in them.

The game can be completed with only a cursory dive into each of its sprawling sub-systems, and at the same time players can spend hours without advancing the main narrative just tooling around. Level-5 would return to these ideas in later games, but never to the same extent or with the depth of character that the world of Dark Chronicle boasts.


Naturally, praise of Dark Chronicle‘s systemic intricacy and aesthetics must be tempered both by time and correction for nostalgia. In the former case, Dark Chronicle‘s graphics were never going to stand up in the HD era the same that The Wind Waker‘s delightful cel-shading does. What’s more is that, since the early 2000s, there have been indie games and mid-range JRPGs that co-opted bits and pieces in gameplay and in world design so that, of course, the game is no longer a perfect example of its genre.

In the latter case, nostalgia cuts like a double-edged sword. The fact that so many PlayStation 2 gamers remember Dark Chronicle fondly is a testament to its popularity and quality. At the same time, the game was not in a vacuum, and plenty of other JRPGs of its era were trying similar kinds of experimentation that are now forgotten.

Nevertheless, the fact that the game still stands with all of its experimental systems makes it a curious reminder of action-RPGs as they were once-upon-a-time. This year’s Kingdom Hearts III feels like a game out of time, because its home was contemporary with Dark Chronicle.

Ni no Kuni Wrath of the White Witch gameplay screenshot

Ni no Kuni, by Rhain Radford-Burns

Another one of OnlySP’s favourite games—one that did not make the final cut but would be remiss in ignoring—is the Ni no Kuni franchise. Conceived in 2008 for Level-5’s tenth anniversary, Ni no Kuni: Dominion of the Dark Djinn was released exclusively in Japan in December 2010 for the Nintendo DS. The game’s animated cutscenes were produced by Studio Ghibli (the Japanese animation house known for films such as Spirited AwayPrincess Mononoke, and My Neighbour Totoro), with the original score provided by longtime Ghibli contributor Joe Hisaishi.

The game felt truly representative of a Studio Ghibli production, and this became more evident with the release of Ni no Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch—an enhanced, 3D version of the DS game—for the PlayStation 3 in November 2011 (and in Western regions in January 2013). The game’s world, narrative, and characters felt alive, and the game remains a testament to the talent of the team at Level-5.

Although Studio Ghibli was not directly involved with Ni no Kuni II: Revenant Kingdom, released for the PlayStation 4 in March 2018, Hisaishi returned to the project alongside former Ghibli artist Yoshiyuki Momose. The game still made a significant impact upon its release—especially at OnlySP, where Damien Lawardorn awarded it a Distinction (4/5) in his final review, and it received six nominations at OnlySP’s Best of 2018 ceremony, including Best Game. We also took a look at the game’s beautiful world in an exclusive video.

Thanks so much for joining us for a look at some incredible JRPGs. Come back next week as we look at another game with great personal significance—one that is much deeper than most on the list to date. In the meantime, you can follow OnlySP on FacebookTwitter, and YouTube, and why not join the OnlySP Discord too?

Continue Reading

OnlySP 50 Favorite Games

OnlySP’s Favorite Games #49—Spec Ops: The Line



Thanks to the staff of OnlySP, I am inviting you to come on a journey through our 50 favourite games. This week we look at a deceptively terrifying tale of war … an epic tragedy in the clothing of a boring shooter.

#49. SPEC OPS: THE LINE, by Sep Gohardani

Looking at the cover of the 2012 shooter Spec Ops: The Line, no one would be blamed for rolling their eyes. The cover shows a man holding a gun aloft, his piercing blue eyes staring intensely, cajoling you towards some mindless, indiscriminate shooting in the style of the most dreary Call of Duty games.

Smoke can be seen in the background, no doubt from one of the many explosions that the player will delight in setting off as they commit wanton murder. A helicopter also menacingly glides through the sky, offering the most generic of seals of approval. Yawn.

Except Spec Ops: The Line is not that game. Retract that yawn, because this is a game that belies expectation, instead proving itself to be the antithesis of a mindless shooter. Spec Ops is a game that puts story first, and heavily emphasises its characters and its setting not just as wallpaper to facilitate the firing of bullets, but as vehicles to tell a gratifying and worthwhile tale.

Spec Ops: The Line gameplay screenshot 5

The game is set amidst a succession of natural disasters in Dubai, which, prior to the game’s events, was beset with a series of intense and horrible sandstorms that are at first downplayed, but which continue to escalate until Dubai is practically rendered unliveable, abandoned by the upper classes and inhabited only by those who cannot escape. War hero Colonel John Konrad is trapped in the city along with his battalion, who he volunteers to try to help with relief efforts despite orders saying he should leave. After little to no communication for an extended period, Captain Martin Walker is sent in alongside a couple of others to try to ascertain what exactly the situation is.

If that description gives you Heart of Darkness vibes, it should, since the game takes a lot of inspiration from it, twisting the classic story to explore similar its themes in a new way. Walker could easily have been the stock grizzled, burly white main character of almost every modern shooter and he starts off that way, but soon, as every good Heart of Darkness adaptation should, the story starts to bend and twist that mould.

Walker and his two NPC companions Adams and Lugo have their preconceptions about what they are going in to, but those are soon challenged as all three are forced to evolve and adapt to the situation. The characterisation in these moments as each of them comes to realise the magnitude of events and what it means for them and their companions is executed well, and a lot of the strength of the game lies in the dialogue between these characters, and how each is affected.

Spec Ops: The Line gameplay screenshot 3

The way their mentality changes as the game progresses is also indicative of the game’s analysis of the themes of heroism and intervention, forcing the player to ponder the idea that their role as saviour is may be questionable after all. It uses that idea to spring a number of surprises, and the more that the line starts to blur and the player is forced to make difficult choices, the more the player realises that the situation is a whole lot more complex than it seemed.

Therein lies the game’s true strength; its handling of its central storyline and the themes associated with it are an example of excellent game writing. The title does not bother with a morality system in the style of an RPG simply because choices are not black and white. The game has no ‘paragon’ or ‘renegade’, only a gradually worsening mess that is snowballing no matter what is done against it. This idea serves to both amplify the tension, making for a more exciting experience, and allows for character development of the central trio. Unlike what its genre counterparts want you to believe, Spec Ops is not afraid to show that war, even in game form, is a whole lot less heroic than it is made out to be.

Both graphically and gameplay wise, the game is pretty unremarkable. The environments are nicely rendered but its counterparts had graphics just as good, if not better at the time. In terms of gameplay, Spec Ops hung its hat on the cover-based combat systems that continue to be so popular in shooter games these days.

Spec Ops: The Line gameplay screenshot 2

In the context of the game, the combat works really well because of the prevalence of guerrilla-esque warfare amidst the nicely animated desert setting and manages to make several set piece fights feel as intense and immersive as they should be, with the aid of an excellent soundtrack and score. One of the game’s triumphs, however, comes in the animation of these fights.

They are not the sanitised, free-for-all funfests of an arcade shooter game, but rather an attempt to show that ‘heroic combat’ is far less heroic than it sounds, and far more gruesome than you expect. This is a game that aims to mitigate the dopamine rush you get from a cool headshot with a gruelling depiction of what that does to the victim’s head. Spec Ops is all about consequences.

Unlike an RPG, the title lacks an option to avoid doing what you are doing once you have doubts about it, and much like the central trio, the player is locked in for better or for worse. So in amidst all the game’s set-pieces and cutscenes, that are impressive and could rival other shooters in the genre, is a lingering sense of regret that the game works hard to achieve. As the characters come to doubt themselves, so do you.

Spec Ops: The Line gameplay screenshot 1

Mention must be given to Nolan North’s performance in the central role of Captain Walker. His performance is one layered with nuance, and of a standard necessary for the player to understand the true gravitas of what Walker goes through over the course of the game. North again plays with the idea of the hero; the grizzled, determined type who does what is right at all costs, and shows what happens when that idea is challenged, and when Walker comes to realise that it has never been that simple. Without that kind of performance, the game certainly would not have been as impactful as it is.

Spec Ops: The Line did not sell well, and those involved in its development have since made clear that it was a harrowing experience to say the least, rubbishing the idea of a sequel. But the game does not need one. This is a game that dared to try something darker, something more thematically interesting and powerful than its counterparts, and it succeeded. The title succeeded not only in being a gripping experience, but in belittling and undermining jingoistic oversimplifications of warfare and the idea of heroism in a complicated conflict, directing its lesson not only at the characters, but also at the player.  As one of the sardonic loading screen hints say: “The United States Army does not condone the killing of unarmed combatants. But this isn’t real, so why should you care?”

Spec Ops: The Line gameplay screenshot 6

Spoiler Corner with Chris Hepburn (SPOILER WARNING!)

Spec Ops: The Line offers a story unlike any other in military games. Players enter a battle—one that dares to show the true horrors of war. For example, the historic White Phosphorus scene has the player kill enemies through computerised imagery, except truth lies elsewhere.

Many times throughout the story, main character Captain Martin Walker receives a radio call from the main antagonist egging him further into battle. Not until the end is the voice revealed to stem from the character’s mental health issues, such as Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, emphasised through flashbacks comparing what the player experienced to what really happened. The mental health issues progress into hallucinations, driving the player to choose their concluding actions—suicide, become a crazed killer, or go home living with the past.

Spec Ops: The Line gameplay screenshot 7

Most war games romanticize war, pitting players against hordes of generic enemies, calling them evil and saying shoot. The challenge of winning is a pull and, usually, the game features a main antagonist written to be despised. Spec Ops: The Line instead pits the player against a typical antagonist but, by the end, the reality of the battle starts to blur. The true enemy is mental illness brought on by the stresses of war. Not every game needs to make a player feel like a hero. Rather, the individual can experience a situation or limitation like they never can elsewhere. For example, in Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice, the player delves into a world ruled by mental health issues, with the objective of getting out the other side somehow and someway.

The part of Specs Ops: The Line that pushes the characters to breaking point is the White Phosphorus moment. Some critics argue that the white phosphorus is a major showing of Walker’s descent into madness. Rather, the scene can (arguably) be read as a representation of the horrors of blindly taking orders or fighting. Taking the method of attack into consideration, the player and characters only see a silhouette of an enemy through thermal imagery.

Spec Ops: The Line gameplay screenshot 8

The player can only blindly relate the just-seen enemy to the white silhouette, eventually confusing a mass of citizens as standing soldiers in the immediacy of battle. The player is blindly looking at who is at the end of the cannon. Through the lens of the cannon, dead enemies do not show the molten skin, nor can their cries of pain and anguish be heard. Furthermore, the player can not tell the difference between a standing soldier and a citizen. Therefore, when the blindfold is pulled off or, rather, the silhouette is detailed, both the player and the characters see the true damage that is done and have to live with it.

Veterans of war can come back with many mental health issues—a major one being PTSD. War is not a happy-go-lucky place; the truth is that the battlefield holds many saddening, scary, and traumatizing moments that can scar a person both physically and mentally.

Spec Ops: The Line gameplay screenshot 9

Spec Ops: The Line dares to tell a story that keeps the player engrossed in the fabrication  of ‘doing the right thing’, just to pull the curtain back, leaving the player with the ultimate choice of how to deal with what has happened. Games have the potential to make people feel or experience a situation that a movie could not, and not every experience in the world is a positive one. While games such as Battlefield and Call of Duty romanticize killing in the name of righteousness, Spec Ops The Line questions what—and how—in war people perceive their actions as ‘right’.

Thanks for joining us again with this disturbing, but fascinating and thoughtfully crafted entry to our 50 favourite games list. Next week’s action extravaganza is certainly much more exciting than disturbing, but no less thoughtful in its examination of conflict from the perspective of a soldier. For the latest from the world of single-player gaming, be sure to bookmark, follow us on FacebookTwitter, and YouTube, and join our community Discord server.

Continue Reading